One of the most difficult parts of bow technique for both students and teachers is achieving smooth bow changes at the frog. I recall spending countless hours in my lessons, working on making my fingers more flexible just to achieve a smooth bow change. When starting your teaching career with beginner students, some pedagogical methods (Suzuki, Ivan Galamian, Elizabeth Green...etc.) suggest limiting bow use to its middle section at first. This method is based on the idea that the middle of the bow offers better balance and control for beginners, enabling them to concentrate on developing proper technique before moving on to full-bow strokes. However, as the student progresses, it's vital to introduce the use of the lower bow early on, incorporating the subtleties of movement.
I have been searching and experimenting different ways to teach my students, and I encountered a book by Taiwanese violin pedagogue 黃輔堂 (Huang Fu-Tang). His book 教教琴・學教琴 offers a practical two-step exercise to refine finger movements critical for elegant bow transitions:
Step-by-Step Practice Exercise (Huang, 58-60):
Step 1: Without the Bow
Extend your left palm upward.
With your right hand, place the fingertip of the thumb against the center of your left palm. Keep the thumb straight.
Gently curve the finger of your right hand, maintaining contact with your left palm.
Straighten and curve repeatedly, building familiarity and flexibility.
Do the same for the right pinky.
Then do it with both the thumb and the pinky at the same time!
Step 2: With the Bow
Hold your bow securely in the left hand and assume your normal bow hold.
Replicate the bending motion from Step 1 while maintaining your bow hold.
For down bows, fingers (including the pinky) gently curve; for up bows, straighten them.
Through this simple exercise, students experience increased control and smoothness at the bow change, significantly improving their overall tone production.
Insights from Bowing Research (Demoucron, 2008)
The practicality of Huang's exercise is supported by the research of Matthias Demoucron, who studied detailed characteristics of bow direction changes in his doctoral thesis. Demoucron emphasizes that smooth bow changes require accurate control and coordination of several parameters, including bow speed, bow force, and bow-bridge distance:
"Acceptable bow changes require accurate control and coordination of a set of bowing parameters, in particular bow speed, bow force and bow-bridge distance. Long practice is required before optimal control is achieved" (Demoucron, 2008, p. 230).
Demoucron further observed that subtle adjustments, such as a slight decrease in bow force right before changing direction, are essential to avoid unwanted scratchy sounds and achieve fluid transitions. His findings underscore the importance of nuanced finger movements at the frog, as these micro-adjustments significantly influence bow control and sound continuity.
Practical Tips for Teachers:
Introduce Huang’s finger exercise early in training, reinforcing students' tactile awareness.
Encourage slow, intentional movements to foster muscle memory.
By incorporating Huang's practical finger exercises, educators can effectively equip students with the sophisticated techniques essential for mastering seamless bow transitions. I am also actively exploring different strategies to help my students build muscle strength. Do you have any suggestions? I'd love to hear them!
References:
黃輔堂 (1995, 2004). [教教琴・學教琴]. Pages 58-60.
Demoucron, Matthias. "On the control of virtual violins: Physical modelling and control of bowed string instruments." Doctoral Thesis, Université Pierre et Marie Curie; Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, 2008.
Commentaires